Since the day I sat in Dave Thomas’s Ruby presentation, I have been a big fan of his. Not to mention his books particularly Pragmatic Programmer. So Whenever I read his blog, I naturally expect something that
I never have to doubt about.
I have always carried a “Yes he is right” attitude when I read his writing, be it a blog or a book. I have a lot of respect for his work.
I must say I was taken by Surprise to see a book coming from the Pragmatic Press called My Job Went to India.
Here is the introduction to that book
Title: My Job Went to India
And All I Got Was This Lousy Book
Author: Chad Fowler
Pages: 200
ISBN: 0-9766940-1-8
Date: August 2005
HINT: It’s not “their” fault, it’s ours…
The American IT job market is slowly coming apart at the seams, and it’s all our fault. Most of us have been stumbling around letting our careers take us where they may, and now we’re surprised when our companies are shipping our jobs overseas for a fraction of the price. It’s time to take control of our careers, and in the process, learn to stay both relevant and employed. This book will show you how to take action to avoid becoming yet another casualty of offshoring.
* Treat your career as a business. Learn how to apply business principles and build your own brand as a software developer.
* Walks you through the process of making intentional choices about technology and domains to invest in.
* Helps you develop a structured plan for keeping your skills up to date and staying competitive.
* Shows you how to market yourself both inside your company and in the industry in general
Introduction Ends
OK here are my Issues with this book
First, It is the title. “My Job Went to India And All I Got Was This Lousy Book”
I am an Indian by birth( yes from the same India this book is talking about) and I dont feel racist or feel hurt.
On the contrary I am quite proud that Indian Software Industry is matured enough that they can compete at levels that make the folks
at pragmatic press write about it, I also work in the same place as a lot of folks who would read this book reside i.e. The United states
of America
I think that Titles speak for a thousand words. Software Engineers like me have migrated to the USA and have been working quite hard in the software industry here. I face the same issues any other American faces. I pay the same taxes,( At one point I actually paid more that a citizen).Authors of these kinds of books tend to forget that millions of Software professionals of Indian Origin are still working here. Potentially lots of people I know could look at me Negatively as I am from that same country that the title of the book is trying to portray simply to bump up Sales..
So when Dave is looking for Catchy phrases as he claims in his blog, he should surely given this a second thought.
Please change the title to something else to make it more meaningful.
Second, Here are some facts
India still constitutes less than one or two percent of the world software and related service markets
The total revenues of the entire software industry in India amount to less than a third of Microsoft revenues
($25,296 million in 2001) and less than 4 percent of the revenues of 25 top U.S. suppliers of software and computer services
Revenue of the largest software firm in India (TCS) is one half the revenue of the 25th software firm in U.S. (Adobe)
With foresighted policies it could become a major force, capturing 5-8 percent of the world market
Or, it could celebrate too early, and stop at one percent of the market as better equipped competitors overtake India
The Indian IT Services and software industry is likely to grow to US$ 22.2 bn, with domestic market revenues of US$ 4.9 bn in FY 2004-05
This is a small fraction compared to what is being portrayed. A lot of this bad press started happening during the elections.
Here are some statistics in PDF format
So what this means to me is most of the jobs are right here in the US still . Instead of crying over nothing , let’s look at ways to improvise skills
( This by the way seems to be the intent of this book)
And lastly,
Almost all the high techs in US, Microsoft, IBM, Cisco, Sun, GE( Jack Welsch Tech centerare moving many of their R&D efforts to Asian countries, India being one of them
And this is not simply due to cheap labor. Most of this on the contrary is due to the highly skilled geek market out in these countries.
The ratio of number of employees with a Software Engineering background ( BS in engineering ) to Non engineers is very high in those parts of the world. In the USA I never see such high ratio of engineers in the software field. So may be there is a lesson to learn here and focus on the core technical skills than the business aspects this book is trying to portray
Oh well
You must be logged in to post a comment.